strathspey@strathspey.org:69473

Chris Ronald

Arthur's Seat - bars 31-32

Feb. 26, 2018, 5:02 p.m. (Message 69473)

Hi Eric, Derek, and Keith,

Goodness me, I thought this issue had been settled. I guess I should add a
comment.  Along with other teachers with whom I have discussed this
question, I believe the correct reading of the last two bars of Arthur's
Seat is that a petronella turn is intended.

There are several reasons.  Firstly, as far as we can tell, the author of
the 18th Century Book (Jack McConachie - JM) always states when dancers
should give hands.  We see no reason why he would not have done so, if that
is what he had in mind, in this instance.

Secondly, JM uses "turn by the right" elsewhere to mean a petronella turn
or something similar.  Take a look at dance #34 in the 18th Century Book,
Mairi Allan, bars 25-28, for example.  It is clear that no hands are given
in this case.

In further support of our interpretation, consider what happens at the end
of the second time through, when 1st couple have to reach the bottom of the
set on the last two bars as 4th couple step up.  For 1st man, that is a
challenging track with a plain petronella turn, but it is practically
impossible for 1st couple if they have to turn partner with the right hand
as well.

Good luck!

Chris.