June 1, 2006, 5:15 p.m. (Message 45444)
Jim Healy <xxxxxxxx@xxxxxxx.xxx> wrote: | John Chambers wrote: | | >For example, the terms "reel" and "jig" are used by both musicians | >and dancers, but with unrelated meanings. And most of them aren't | >even aware of the problem. | | Until the dancer asks a piper to play a 'jig' Yeah. And over the years, I've played for a lot of Morris and related dance styles, where "jig" simply means a solo dance. The music can be just about any rhythm, though most that I've heard or played were hornpipes. I've read a couple of places that "jig" originated as a term for lively, bouncy dances, mostly of the sort where the dancer is occasionally airborn. How musicians came to use the term for one particular rhythm seems to be a bit of a historical mystery. The same things seems to happened with "reel", which apparently started life as a term for the sort of dance figures where you weave or zig-zag among the other dancers. This is still how dancers use the term, but somehow musicians decided to apply it to a particular sort of very busy duple rhythm. A reel can be done to music in any rhythm, so this was a nonsensical use of the word. My general theory is that most of these things happen through various sorts of misunderstandings. If you watch interactions between dancers who aren't musicians and musicians who aren't dancers, you'll see all sorts of miscommunications. It sometimes seems amazing that the two crowds manage to communicate at all, despite their obvious symbiotic relationship throughout history. How little is actually known about all this is illustrated by the Oxford Dictionary, where the "jig" entry says "XVI. of unkn. orig." and the reel entry says "OE. hreol, of which no cogns. are known." One of my favorite anecdotes on the topic is the report a couple of years back from some astrophysicists, who had discovered that one stable solution to the Three Body Problem is an orbit that they called the Scottish Reel (for 3). In looking for stable orbits of N bodies, they had calculated that you could place three bodies of roughly equal mass in a straight line, and give them all a push that results in them following this familiar dance figure until an outide force disturbs them. As far as I've read, no actual example of this orbit is known. One likely place for it is at the so-called Trojan Points in a heavy planet's orbit around the sun. There are groups of asteroids known to be at these points in the orbits of Jupiter and Saturn, so it's possible that some of them are doing a reel for 3. Studying them isn't easy, but this is on the To-Do lists of a number of astronomers. Whether they'll be found to be dancing to any special rhythm in the Music of the Spheres is a topic for further research. -- _, O John Chambers <:#/> <xx@xxxxxxxx.xxx.xxx> + <xxxxxx@xxxxx.xxx> /#\ in Waltham, Massachusetts, USA, Earth | | ' `