> Are you seriously implying that "the pipes" can only play pipe marches ? > The repertoire is huge. Regarding the Lilt - play a slip jig and you > will simply confuse the dancers. Most Highland dancers will "click" into > the dance if you play Battle of the Somme as the first tune.
Yes, but that's just because highland dancers have that music pounded
into them when they are very young and easily indoctrinated, possibly
for lack of pipers who can/will play the real Lilt music at competitions
(I'm obviously out on a limb here, not being a piper myself).
For the Lilt, the book specifies »Drops of Brandy« and »Brose and
Butter«. Both are 9/8 jigs, not retreat marches, and they have a
completely different feel to them in the dance -- much more lively and
»dancey« where »Battle of the Somme« just seems to drag you along with
it. They also happen not to sit so well on the pipes; you can probably
play tunes that sound vaguely similar but it's not the same thing.
PS. (General remark) Please, please DO try NOT to quote ALL of the
previous message(s) at the bottom of yours. I'm beginning to consider
software that will bounce a contribution back to its sender if
it has a line saying »-----Original Message-----« and there are
more lines below that line than above :^)
Anselm Lingnau .......................................... email@example.com
Giving money and power to government is like giving whiskey and car keys to
teenage boys. -- P. J. O'Rourke
>Please, please DO try NOT to quote ALL of the > previous message(s) ... I'm beginning to consider > software that will bounce a contribution back if > it has a line saying »-----Original Message-----« and there are > more lines below that line than above :^)
Good idea !
Seems more logical to put the relevant quote at the top anyway, so that
readers will know what you are refering to before reading your message
rather than after.