John's dance for Roy?

Ian Brockbank

Message 53820 · 15 Oct 2008 21:18:44 · Fixed-width font · Whole thread

Previous message: dancing in Manhattan (Susan McKinnell)
Next message: John's dance for Roy? (Bruce Herbold)
Previous in thread: John's dance for Roy? (Rebecca Sager)
Next in thread: John's dance for Roy? (Bruce Herbold)

Hi Bruce,

> ...
> I do not really 'get' why John specifies skip-change for the two hand
> turns, although it is consistent with his recent dances with
> petronella turns using skip-change
> ...

Indeed. After all, skip-change is the natural step to use for 2-hand turns,
as Allie* so rightly said. Unfortunately, Allie and Jean+ never saw eye to
eye, so because Allie said skip-change, Jean said pas-de-basque, and most
people seem to have listened to Jean over Allie. So we in Edinburgh are the
only ones to dance it properly.

If you don't believe me that skip-change is natural, try doing Gates of
Edinburgh or set to and turn corners both ways and see which one works
better...

* Miss Allie Anderson, co-founder of the SCDS and Edinburgh Branch
+ Miss Jean Milligan, co-founder of the SCDS and Glasgow Branch

Disclaimer: I wasn't there and never met either of the individuals involved,
so this is a story I have written based on comments from people who did know
the two. Its level of accuracy is unverified...but it does explain why we
do one thing and everyone else does another...

Oh, and apologies if anyone is horrified by the irreverent tone of reference
to these two august personages to whom we have so much to be thankful for.
And apologies to non-native English speakers who found that last sentence
too complicated...

Cheers,

Cheers,
Ian Brockbank
Edinburgh, Scotland
xxx@xxxxxxxxxxxxx.xxx
http://www.scottishdance.net/
** Thanks to everyone who sponsored me for the Great North Run. My disabled
nephew Matthew and others like him will benefit. **
** Details of my run are now up at http://www.justgiving.com/ianbrockbank **

Previous message: dancing in Manhattan (Susan McKinnell)
Next message: John's dance for Roy? (Bruce Herbold)
Previous in thread: John's dance for Roy? (Rebecca Sager)
Next in thread: John's dance for Roy? (Bruce Herbold)
A Django site.